(Moved to

Profits versus the Poor

“I have lost a son, maybe I’ll lose another, but I won’t let them setup a coalmine here.” To Tahmina Begum who had lost her son Toriqul to police bullets, her land was also her family. It could have been a ‘B’ rated western except that it is set in the east. People wanting to hang on to their ancestral land versus mining companies wanting huge profits. There have been only minor changes from previous scripts. When farmers wanted fertilizers and seeds, the police had opened fire killing them, when they wanted electricity to irrigate their soil, the police had opened fire killing them. Now that they want to retain their land rather than have it converted into coal mines again the police have opened fire killing them. The Shaotals, being indigenous minority groups, find themselves even more vulnerable within this persecuted community. In the shootings on the 26th September 2006, in Phulbari, Dinajpur, in northwestern Bangladesh, at least six villagers are known to have been killed, over a hundred are said to be missing.

Reminiscent of his predecessors on this land, Gary Lye, the CEO of the British company Asia Energy Corporation (Bangladesh) Pty Ltd, which wants the mining rights, denied the Phulbari project would harm the environment saying it would benefit local people instead. He did add “It is up to the authorities to determine exactly what happened, but it would appear that the unforgivable events and the needless loss of life and suffering that took place yesterday in Phulbari are entirely the fault of the organisers (of the protest).”

It had been the fault of the farmers when they wanted fertilizers and seeds, it had been their fault when they wanted electricity to irrigate their lands. It was now the fault of Tahmina Begum and her son Toriqul, for wanting to stay on land that was their own.

The poor deal that Bangladesh appears to be getting, the massive profits predicted for Asia Energy, The foot dragging on the investigation of Nasreen’s death, are suspicious on their own. The close friendship between Asia Energy and Bangladeshi government officials that has emerged looks ominously close to Shell’s friendship with General Abacha. Despite this friendship, faced by the massive protest of over 20,000 people, the government has again had to back down, but with the increasing appetite for energy of war hungry nations, and with pliant governments ready to please in the hope of hanging on to power. Tahmina Begum might well lose the other family member that she has nurtured and tilled all her life. The west meanwhile continues to promote ‘freedom and democracy’ worldwide.

Photos: Munim Wasef/DrikNews.

Text: Shahidul Alam

September 4, 2006 - Posted by | Sites of Drik and Pathshala photographers


  1. this is beautiful

    Comment by cabalistic | September 7, 2006 | Reply

  2. When will we all stand up… everywhere… as big companies and big government annihilate us at every turn. Is it worse now, or has it always been this way and I have not “seen” it.
    Every day there are 50 transgressions and perhaps one rectification, then 50 more transgressions the next day and so on.

    These photographs are so important.

    Comment by pbsweeney | September 12, 2006 | Reply

  3. I wish the press would really dig in. We would like to know who the “freinds” of Asia Energy are. Who paid whom and when and how much.

    Comment by Salam Dhaka | October 4, 2006 | Reply

  4. I scrolled down your website and photo after photo..your work has ceased to impress me…. I am a freelance artist with a passion for the paints on canvas but your frozen flats of life are powerful have instilled a new appreciation within me..i look forward to seeing more. Keep up the stimulating work. x

    Comment by Rahima | December 17, 2006 | Reply

  5. Your countrys impoverished state continues because you will not let development and economic modernisation progress. With a proportion of the revenues generated from the mine going to the local people, why would you not want to capitalise from this project and let your lives prosper? Foreigners are continuously stopped from investing in countries like Bangladesh and trying to assist in the economic modernisation of the country, this looks poor on you and until this stance changes you will always suffer from the consequences. Unfortunately things have to be forfeited for the rest of your country to progress and achieve at least self sufficient power generation. You cant have it both ways unfortunately.

    Comment by John Neil | May 13, 2007 | Reply

    • The business would lose a lot of money if the ratio is inversely proportional. This means the extra money and resources invested do not increase the amount of raw materials derived from the rabbits.

      Comment by how to take professional pictures | February 11, 2012 | Reply

  6. If this project does not go ahead then it will look terribly bad to foreign investors in Bangladesh. Countries and companies are waiting on standby to invest in the future of Bangladesh and bring prosperity to the peoples. This is not the right image you should be portraying to foreign parties right now.

    Comment by Wasim Khan | May 28, 2007 | Reply

  7. FYI:

    Comment by zakir kibria | September 3, 2007 | Reply

  8. prothom chobite je mohilar chobi dekha jachche tini toriqul er ma non. ami toriqul er ma ke meet korechi. apni ki arekbar check korben?

    Comment by nasrin siraj annie | September 4, 2007 | Reply

  9. […] versus the poor Republished from ShahidulNews. Photo: Munem Wasif/DrikNews Text: Shahidul […]

    Pingback by Profits versus the poor « BanglaPraxis | October 25, 2007 | Reply

  10. […] Panos Radio podcasts report on Phulbari resistance Photo: Shahidul Alam […]

    Pingback by Panos Radio podcasts report on Phulbari resistance « BanglaPraxis | October 29, 2007 | Reply

  11. […] Photo: Munem Wasif/DrikNews  […]

    Pingback by Phulbari communities write to ADB President and Executive Directors « BanglaPraxis | December 20, 2007 | Reply

  12. Urgent Appeal by World Orgnization against Torture (OMCT): Risk of Violent Suppression of Public Opposition to the Phulbari Coal Mine Project

    Comment by Webmaster | December 25, 2007 | Reply

  13. Phulbari Communities Write to ADB President and Executive Directors

    Comment by Webmaster | December 25, 2007 | Reply

  14. Send a letter to GCM/AEC: Don’t undermine Bangladesh

    Comment by Webmaster | April 8, 2008 | Reply

  15. Blow for British coal company’s controversial mining plans

    Comment by Webmaster | April 8, 2008 | Reply

  16. Wonderful post i will visit again=)

    Comment by GepeephewaH | May 20, 2009 | Reply

  17. Myślę, że jest to jeden z wyjątkowych artykułów na jakie trafiłam.
    Jestem zafascynowana, że mogłam poznać inny punkt widzenia.
    Proszę o więcej:).

    Comment by | November 23, 2012 | Reply

  18. Cenię wartość informacji, które zamieszczasz na blogu.
    Czytanie ich to sama radość. Styl witryny jest bez zarzutu, natomiast artykuły są de facto
    świetne:D Dobra robota:) Pozdrawiam.

    Comment by Amber | November 28, 2012 | Reply

  19. I needed to share this unique blog post, “Profits versus the Poor ShahidulNews” along with my own
    close friends on facebook itself. I actuallymerely desired to spread ur
    outstanding publishing! Thank you, Cecil

    Comment by | February 10, 2013 | Reply

  20. Thanks for another fantastic post. Where else could

    anyone get that kind of info in such a perfect way of writing?
    I’ve a

    presentation next week, and I’m on the look for such information.

    Comment by | January 28, 2014 | Reply

  21. Greetings from Colorado! I’m bored to tears at

    work so I decided to check out your website on my iphone
    during lunch break. I

    love the knowledge you present here and can’t wait
    to take a look when I get home. I’m

    amazed at how fast your blog loaded on my phone .. I’m not even using WIFI,

    just 3G .. Anyways, good blog!

    Comment by Collin | February 23, 2014 | Reply

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: